Tennessee settles $70,000 claim with singer after blood test shows sobriety
The state board of claims approved the payout for Stefanie Fair, whose 2024 arrest was part of a wider pattern of DUI stops for sober drivers.
By Vanessa Lopez ·

The Tennessee Highway Patrol will pay $70,000 to Stefanie Fair to settle a dispute over her 2024 drunk driving arrest. Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, was found to be sober at the time of the stop according to subsequent blood work. The state board of claims has approved the agreement, and the attorney general’s office said the money should reach her within the next few weeks.
Trooper Keith Velez told court records that he smelled a distinct odor of alcohol on Fair or inside her vehicle. Fair disputed this, stating she does not drink alcohol. Video footage from the scene shows her eating ice cream shortly before the arrest. She described the experience of being detained as frightening, noting she was more scared while with the trooper alone than she was once inside the jail.
Ben Raybin, Fair’s attorney, said the settlement indicates the state acknowledges many of these arrests are legally weak. He argued that if the cases went to a jury trial, a jury would likely rule in favor of the drivers. Raybin pointed out that Tennessee law currently offers no direct way for sober drivers to recover costs after charges are dismissed, leaving a lawsuit as the only legal option.
Fair is the second sober driver to reach a settlement with the highway patrol. Thomas Manis received $75,000 after state troopers arrested him for drunk driving in East Tennessee. The issue has drawn attention to specific officers. WSMV4 Investigates reported that Trooper James Zahn arrested Jane Bondurant, a former U.S. attorney, while she was sober. Bondurant was the eighth known sober driver arrested by Zahn.
A lawsuit filed this year by a man from Thompson Station alleges that Zahn also arrested him for drunk driving while he was sober. If that claim holds up, Zahn would have nine sober drivers on record. Other agencies in the region have also paid out settlements. Court records show the Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and the La Vergne police have settled similar claims from drivers who were found to be sober after their arrests.
The pattern of claims continues to grow. Labreesha Batey, a NASA employee, is among other sober drivers who have filed suits against the state. These legal actions follow investigations that documented multiple instances where officers reported smelling alcohol, but laboratory tests later proved the drivers had no alcohol in their systems.






