AdvertiseDonate
Los AngelesNew YorkChicagoHoustonPhoenixPhiladelphiaSan FranciscoSeattleAtlantaBoston
Wednesday, November 18, 2026News you can follow.
Global Newz Hub · 111 North Market Street, Suite 300, San Jose, CA 95113

Latest stories

  1. Wellcome Backs Major Study of Britain's Planned Social Media Ban for Children
  2. 'Aarigaa': Mary Peltola becomes first Alaska Native to win a seat in the US Senate
  3. El-Sayed urges new Israeli leaders to face accountability for Gaza war
  4. Israeli attorney general freezes E1 settlement tender process until new government sworn in
  5. US Air Traffic Control Crisis Sparks Calls to Follow Canada's Privatized Model

Otzma Yehudit Proposes Bill to Restrict Law of Return Conversions

A new bill seeks to limit immigration rights to those converted according to Jewish religious law, challenging a recent High Court ruling.

By Amir Navarro ·

Illustration for: Otzma Yehudit Proposes Bill to Restrict Law of Return Conversions
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Two days after the swearing-in of the 26th Knesset, the Otzma Yehudit party submitted a bill to amend Israel's Law of Return. The proposal aims to restrict the state's recognition of Jewish conversions to those performed strictly according to halacha, or Jewish religious law. This move seeks to effectively overturn a landmark High Court of Justice ruling that previously recognized Reform and Conservative conversions for purposes of immigration and population registration.

The bill, introduced by MK Limor Son Har-Melech, adds specific language to the legal definition of a Jew. Under the proposed text, a Jew is defined as someone born to a Jewish mother who is not a member of another religion, or someone who converted according to halacha. The sponsors argue that this legislation represents a legitimate exercise of legislative sovereignty, noting that former Supreme Court President Esther Hayut had previously stated that the Knesset was entitled to define the term conversion differently through future laws.

The legal context for this bill dates back to 2021, when an expanded panel of nine justices issued what became known as the Dahan ruling. The court determined that the state must recognize Reform and Conservative conversions performed within recognized Jewish communities in Israel for Law of Return purposes. The ruling emphasized that the matter was civil rather than religious. However, the new bill intends to render that specific recognition meaningless by imposing the halachic requirement.

Ambiguity surrounds the definition of converting according to halacha, as the bill does not explicitly define the term. Halachic practice is not uniform, and questions remain regarding which authority would determine compliance. Whether the Chief Rabbinate or private Orthodox rabbinical courts hold this authority is unclear. This distinction is critical because private Orthodox conversion initiatives, such as Giyur K'Halacha, convert approximately 220 people annually, a number comparable to the Reform movement's annual figure of 234 and higher than the Conservative movement's 92.

The bill also has significant implications for conversions performed abroad. The High Court has recognized Diaspora Reform and Conservative conversions for registry purposes since the late 1980s. According to an analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute, the new bill would no longer grant eligibility for aliyah to those who underwent such conversions overseas. This is a notable shift given that only 9% of Jewish adults in the United States identify as Orthodox, compared to 37% Reform and 17% Conservative, according to a Pew Research Center survey.

Historically, the Knesset has been cautious about adding the phrase according to halacha to the Law of Return. In 1970, following the Shalit ruling, lawmakers included a definition of a Jew but deliberately avoided that specific wording to prevent a rupture with Diaspora Jewry. Prime ministers from both the Right and Left have resisted such changes for over 50 years. In the final days of the previous Knesset, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked an identical proposal from MK Simcha Rothman due to concerns about the reaction from the Jewish diaspora.

The bill does not repeal the grandchild clause, meaning individuals with a Jewish grandparent can still immigrate as family members, though they would not be registered as Jewish. However, those who underwent non-Orthodox conversions and lack other qualifying relatives could lose their right to immigrate. In numerical terms, the High Court ruling affected a relatively small group, averaging about 326 Reform and Conservative converts annually in Israel, compared to thousands who convert through state or military systems.

Supporters of the proposal argue that the legislation addresses a long-standing issue by ensuring unity in Jewish religious law. They contend that the bill prevents the state from recognizing individuals as Jewish who cannot marry or be buried under Chief Rabbinate rules. MK Simcha Rothman has maintained that the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism but to prevent an influx of fictitious or lenient conversions conducted specifically for immigration purposes.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Global Newz Hub in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Global Newz Hub in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.