AdvertiseDonate
Los AngelesNew YorkChicagoHoustonPhoenixPhiladelphiaSan FranciscoSeattleAtlantaBoston
Wednesday, November 18, 2026News you can follow.
Global Newz Hub · 111 North Market Street, Suite 300, San Jose, CA 95113

Latest stories

  1. Wellcome Backs Major Study of Britain's Planned Social Media Ban for Children
  2. 'Aarigaa': Mary Peltola becomes first Alaska Native to win a seat in the US Senate
  3. El-Sayed urges new Israeli leaders to face accountability for Gaza war
  4. Israeli attorney general freezes E1 settlement tender process until new government sworn in
  5. US Air Traffic Control Crisis Sparks Calls to Follow Canada's Privatized Model
World · Israel and Gaza

Israel's Otzma Yehudit proposes strict halachic standard for Law of Return

A new bill seeks to limit immigration rights to those converted according to Jewish religious law, challenging a 2021 Supreme Court ruling that accepted Reform and Conservative conversions.

By Vanessa Lopez ·

Illustration for: Israel's Otzma Yehudit proposes strict halachic standard for Law of Return
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Otzma Yehudit submitted a bill to the Knesset on November 15, 2026, aiming to amend Israel’s Law of Return by restricting eligibility for immigration to those converted according to halacha. The proposal, filed by MK Limor Son Har-Melech two days after the swearing-in of the 26th Knesset, seeks to overturn the 2021 Dahan ruling. That High Court of Justice decision established that Reform and Conservative conversions performed within recognized communities in Israel must be recognized for immigration and registration purposes.

The bill adds a specific clause to the legal definition of a Jew. Under the proposal, a Jew is defined as a person born to a Jewish mother who is not a member of another religion, or a person who converted according to halacha. The legislation does not provide a definition for the term according to halacha. This omission creates uncertainty regarding which religious authorities qualify to perform such conversions. The Supreme Rabbinical Court previously annulled conversions performed by the state system in 2008 and 2009, a practice the High Court halted in 2012.

Former Supreme Court president Esther Hayut noted in the 2021 ruling that the Knesset retained the power to define conversion differently through future legislation. This legal precedent supports the bill’s sponsors in characterizing the move as a sovereign legislative decision rather than an attempt to circumvent the court. However, the ambiguity of the term allows for various interpretations. It could refer exclusively to Chief Rabbinate approvals, which might affect converts from private Orthodox initiatives like Giyur K’Halacha. Alternatively, courts could interpret it to include the religious laws of any Jewish denomination.

The bill makes no distinction between conversions performed in Israel and those conducted abroad. According to an analysis by the Israel Democracy Institute, this change would remove the right of aliyah for those who underwent Reform or Conservative conversions overseas. This represents a shift from earlier High Court decisions in 1986 and 1987, which recognized such foreign conversions for population registry purposes. The Jewish Agency and Diaspora organizations have previously warned that similar proposals could cause a rift with world Jewry.

Demographic data underscores the potential impact on international relations. A Pew Research Center survey indicates that only 9% of Jewish adults in the United States identify as Orthodox. By comparison, 37% identify as Reform and 17% as Conservative. The bill does not repeal the grandchild clause of the Law of Return. Individuals with a Jewish grandparent would still be eligible to immigrate as family members, though they would not be registered as Jewish. However, a convert without a Jewish relative or eligible spouse under the new definition could lose the right to immigrate.

The proposed change reverses a long-standing political compromise. In 1970, lawmakers added Section 4B to the Law of Return following the Shalit ruling but deliberately omitted the phrase according to halacha. Prime ministers from both the right and left resisted adding those words for over 50 years. In the final days of the 25th Knesset, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blocked an identical proposal by MK Simcha Rothman due to concerns about Diaspora reactions. The current bill is therefore a fundamental alteration of the status quo rather than a return to a previous arrangement.

Numerical data suggests the ruling affects a small group within Israel. An average of 326 Reform and Conservative converts were processed annually in the country, compared with thousands through the state system and the IDF. Public opinion remains divided. An Israel Democracy Institute survey found that 46% of Israeli Jews recognize non-Orthodox converts as Jewish, while 39% do not. The same survey showed that 46% believe Diaspora representatives should be included in discussions about Law of Return changes.

Supporters argue the bill addresses a fundamental issue the Knesset has avoided for decades. They contend that requiring conversion according to halacha ensures unity in Jewish religious law. This prevents a scenario where the state recognizes individuals as Jewish for immigration purposes while the Chief Rabbinate denies them marriage or burial rights. MK Simcha Rothman has stated that the intention is not to harm liberal Judaism but to prevent fictitious conversions or those conducted under lenient standards for immigration.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Global Newz Hub in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Global Newz Hub in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.