District Attorneys Demand California High Court Halt Newsom's Death Penalty Commutations
Prosecutors from 30 counties argue the governor bypassed legal duties by failing to notify victims before proposing to spare 548 inmates on death row.
By Amir Navarro ·

District attorneys from 30 California counties filed a lawsuit on Monday asking the state Supreme Court to stop Governor Gavin Newsom’s proposed commutations for 548 prisoners sentenced to death. The legal challenge claims the governor acted illegally by failing to give crime victims or their families a chance to be heard before moving to alter the sentences. The plaintiffs argue that only the state's highest court can check what they describe as the governor’s disregard for statutory requirements.
Newsom first imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019. He later ordered the dismantling of the execution chamber at San Quentin State Prison. As his term nears its end, his administration has moved to finalize these clemency actions. The incoming governor, Xavier Becerra, has pledged to extend the execution pause when he takes office. Despite this continuity in policy, the proposed commutations have triggered immediate legal resistance from local prosecutors.
The complaint distinguishes between the unlimited clemency power of a U.S. president and the specific rules governing California governors. State law requires a governor to notify the district attorney and the victims or their families when a death row prisoner requests a commutation. The plaintiffs contend that Newsom ignored these procedural steps for all 548 individuals included in his proposal.
In a written explanation, Newsom argued that the notification requirements did not apply because none of the 548 prisoners had personally requested a commutation. He stated that the section of the penal code cited by the prosecutors does not trigger when a governor acts on their own initiative rather than responding to a prisoner’s petition. The governor’s office added that it would inform local district attorneys and request their assistance with notifications after the Supreme Court files the proposals.
The state Supreme Court is already reviewing nearly 400 of the cases in this group. State law mandates this judicial review because the inmates were convicted of multiple serious felonies. Court representatives have not yet outlined the timeline or method for conducting these individual reviews.
The filing sets up a direct conflict between the governor’s executive office and the state’s highest judicial authority. The court must decide whether the governor’s unilateral action violates the notification statutes or if the nature of the proposal exempts it from those rules. The outcome will determine the legal standing of the 548 commutations before the new administration takes charge in January.






